Montréal

Juan GutierrezMortgage broker · Quebec

Mortgage penalty: what the law guarantees, what the contract decides

If you are searching for an abusive mortgage penalty, you have probably been handed a number that looks nothing like what you were told. Two things to know before accepting it: federal law guarantees you a ceiling in one specific case, and it obliges your lender to have explained its method of calculation. The rest — the method itself — is in your contract, not in the law.

By Juan Gutierrez · Mortgage Broker · Updated

Key facts
RuleFigureSource
After five yearsThree months' interest · for a mortgage whose principal is not payable until more than five years after its date, then after the expiration of those five years, “together with three months further interest in lieu of notice”Interest Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. I-15, s. 10 · current to 19 October 2026
The exceptionDoes not apply · to a mortgage given by a joint stock company or any other corporationInterest Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. I-15, s. 10 · current to 19 October 2026
The lender's dutyEvery component of the calculation · the initial disclosure statement must describe any components that comprise the formula used to calculate a rebate, charge or penalty on prepaymentSOR/2021-181, s. 40(1)(l) · current to 19 October 2026
Non-interest chargesR = A × ((n – m)/n) · the refund formula prescribed by the Regulations on a full repaymentSOR/2021-181, s. 11(2)
Not in the cost of borrowingExcluded · the cost of borrowing does not include “penalty charges for the prepayment of a loan”SOR/2021-181, s. 48(2)(d) · current to 19 October 2026

What does the law guarantee you?

One ceiling, and it is precise. The Interest Act provides that where principal secured by a mortgage is not, under the terms of the mortgage, payable until a time more than five years after its date, then after the expiration of those five years the person liable to pay may tender the principal and interest due “together with three months further interest in lieu of notice”, and no further interest is chargeable.

In other words: beyond five years, the legal ceiling is three months' interest. Below it — and the great majority of residential mortgages have a term of five years or less — that ceiling does not apply, and the contract decides.

The same Act withholds this right for a mortgage given by a joint stock company or any other corporation. If you hold an income property through a company, that ceiling is not yours — a detail the general pages on this subject do not mention.

So how does the lender calculate it?

By one of two methods, depending on the contract: three months' interest, or an interest rate differential — the gap between your rate and the rate at which the lender can place the money again, multiplied by the balance and by the time remaining. On a fixed rate in a falling market, the differential produces amounts far higher than three months' interest.

Both methods are conventions of the contract, not rules of law: neither appears in the federal Regulations. What the Regulations impose is transparency — which means your lender's exact method exists in writing, and you are entitled to have it.

What must you have been told in writing?

The information box in your credit agreement must state the amount of the penalty charges, if any, for prepayment of the loan, and a brief explanation of the manner in which those penalty charges are calculated. The initial disclosure statement goes further: it requires a description of any components that comprise the formula used to calculate a rebate, charge or penalty if you repay before maturity. Both official versions of the Regulations, French and English, require it in the same terms.

This is the most useful lever on this page. You do not have to guess the formula or trust an online calculator: it must be in your documents. And if the figure you are quoted cannot be rebuilt from what is written there, that is a legitimate question to ask, in writing, before you pay.

Why did the rate you compared tell you nothing?

Because the penalty is not part of it. The Regulations explicitly exclude penalty charges for the prepayment of a loan from the cost of borrowing. Two offers at the same advertised rate can therefore carry very different penalties, and nothing in the rate signals it.

That is why it is worth comparing the prepayment clause when you choose the lender, and not when you leave. A gap of a few hundredths of a point on the rate can be wiped out by a costlier penalty method if you sell or refinance before the end of the term.

If you already have a number in hand: keep the initial disclosure, ask for the detailed calculation in writing, and have the two read together. That is exactly the kind of file a broker who places loans with these lenders reads every day.

Frequently asked questions

Are three months' interest a right in every case?
No. The Interest Act gives that ceiling for a mortgage whose principal is not payable until more than five years after its date, and only after the expiration of those five years. Most residential terms are five years or less, and in that case the contract sets the method.
Why is my figure far higher than three months' interest?
Most likely because your contract provides for an interest rate differential rather than three months. On a fixed rate, when market rates have fallen since signing, that method produces much larger amounts. The exact method must appear in your initial disclosure statement.
Can a penalty be disputed?
The right first step is not a dispute, it is a verification: ask in writing for the detailed calculation and compare it with the method described in your documents. The federal Regulations oblige the lender to have stated how the penalty is calculated, which makes the question entirely legitimate.
Is the penalty included in the advertised rate?
No, and the Regulations say so: the cost of borrowing does not include penalty charges for the prepayment of a loan. Two loans at the same rate can therefore cost very differently if you leave before the end of the term, without the advertised rate showing it.

Let's talk about your project.

A first conversation with no obligation, to know how much you can borrow and which documents to prepare.